What's new

Erie hogs hair

Carwashking

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
53
Points
28
Location
Dallas
Starting about a year ago we started encountering de-lamination of the adhesive that seals the hog’s hair in the head. We are finding that plugs of hair are falling out and causing premature brush failure. We use about 200 EB212570 heads a year for over 30 years we notified the company and they seem to not stand behind their product and not offer a solution. I am out about $4000 on the batch of brushes we returned to them and will never purchase anything from this company again. It is not a chemical issue because universal brush or hog daddy does not show similar issues. My advice is anyone who is buying a Erie made product to go inspect their product and make a decision on for themselves whether you should continue to buy their product
 

Attachments

OurTown

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
3,680
Reaction score
1,430
Points
113
Location
Ohio
We had similar but not as bad issues with Erie brushes last year. I called and they acted like we were the only ones that had the issue and shrugged it off. It's too bad because for the same price they have more hair than the Universal heads that we bought. The Universal heads just seem cheap looking in comparison. I was thinking of giving Erie another chance thinking it was a fluke but after this post I may not.
 

Keno

Well-known member
Joined
May 30, 2022
Messages
775
Reaction score
505
Points
93
Starting about a year ago we started encountering de-lamination of the adhesive that seals the hog’s hair in the head. We are finding that plugs of hair are falling out and causing premature brush failure. We use about 200 EB212570 heads a year for over 30 years we notified the company and they seem to not stand behind their product and not offer a solution. I am out about $4000 on the batch of brushes we returned to them and will never purchase anything from this company again. It is not a chemical issue because universal brush or hog daddy does not show similar issues. My advice is anyone who is buying a Erie made product to go inspect their product and make a decision on for themselves whether you should continue to buy their product
Wow - 200 heads per year and they can't be bothered...we have had issues with Erie heads also and moved away from them about a year or 2 ago to hog daddy and hog king brushes. Both have worked well for us.

On another note - bravo to you for needing 200 brush heads a year! That's some wash volume!
 

Carwashking

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
53
Points
28
Location
Dallas
Wow - 200 heads per year and they can't be bothered...we have had issues with Erie heads also and moved away from them about a year or 2 ago to hog daddy and hog king brushes. Both have worked well for us.

On another note - bravo to you for needing 200 brush heads a year! That's some wash volume!
 

Keno

Well-known member
Joined
May 30, 2022
Messages
775
Reaction score
505
Points
93
We use the metal ones, but the paint does flake off before the brush wears out a lot of the time on the hog daddy.

Hog king we use metal also, no issues with paint on those.

Both get good life, better than we got with Erie. Foaming pattern is not as good as Erie, but still gets nice and foamy.
 

Earl Weiss

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2007
Messages
6,384
Reaction score
948
Points
113
I suggest you call Erie and ask to talk to Jason Ugent (the boss) - he seems very responsive.
 

Carwashking

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
53
Points
28
Location
Dallas
I was dealing with the owner of Kleenrite. After 3 months of unsatisfactory results from Erie Kleenrite at there expense he is given me 22 heads. Erie only said they would give me two. I’m sure this was a problem way before I listened to my manager when he told me about a year ago hair was missing in areas of the brush. I just ignored him about this. I’m hoping to get all of the brushes back and tell Keith to not give me anything free on his end. I will decide if I seek a legal remedy for my total exposure of my loss. Let’s say I have purchased 5000 bushes over 30 years and I for the first time see a defect and they have chosen to not stand by the product of the long term customer. This should have taken a week and a new batch of product should have been sent to me. We also noticed the hair color on the brush heads are now solid black.
 

washnshine

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 21, 2014
Messages
2,006
Reaction score
1,557
Points
113
Location
NY
There are also Inkfish brushes. I never tried them, but it is another alternative.
 

HeyVern

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 27, 2021
Messages
410
Reaction score
475
Points
63
After reading this thread yesterday, I checked my brushes and one that I installed about 2 months ago is missing clumps of bristles. I have round Erie brushes in the other bays and they don't appear to be having this problem.
 

Carwashking

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
53
Points
28
Location
Dallas
We had similar issues but what we noticed first is the to glue will begin to delaminate and then it will start loose plugs. We are also concerned about the sharpness of the glue scratch the paint and I could be liable
 

Attachments

Earl Weiss

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2007
Messages
6,384
Reaction score
948
Points
113
. I’m sure this was a problem way before I listened to my manager when he told me about a year ago hair was missing in areas of the brush. I just ignored him about this.
Are you saying you noticed something a year ago and still got another year of use out of them? How long did they usually last before you had this issue?
 

Carwashking

Active member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
116
Reaction score
53
Points
28
Location
Dallas
Are you saying you noticed something a year ago and still got another year of use out of them? How long did they usually last before you had this issue?
No we average about 3 months for our brushes My manager notified me hair was falling out of heads and I just instructed him to replace with new one. I wish any brand would last a year
 

Mchas

Active member
Joined
Jun 15, 2019
Messages
169
Reaction score
47
Points
28
I also have the same problem but not quite that bad. I contacted Erie a few years back about this exact issue and they replaced a few brush heads for me under warranty but not without a bit of a fight. They also claimed they were changing their manufacturing process to avoid these issues but I guess that wasn’t true. I also noticed the brushes are much darker in color than they used to be.

If anyone has a good alternative I am open to trying a different brand.
 

wyatt

Active member
Joined
Nov 12, 2018
Messages
244
Reaction score
56
Points
28
Location
northwest
Just go with universal. Never had an issue and they typically last me almost a year if you use the monster ones
 

Erie Brush

New member
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
3
Reaction score
13
Points
3
Starting about a year ago we started encountering de-lamination of the adhesive that seals the hog’s hair in the head. We are finding that plugs of hair are falling out and causing premature brush failure. We use about 200 EB212570 heads a year for over 30 years we notified the company and they seem to not stand behind their product and not offer a solution. I am out about $4000 on the batch of brushes we returned to them and will never purchase anything from this company again. It is not a chemical issue because universal brush or hog daddy does not show similar issues. My advice is anyone who is buying a Erie made product to go inspect their product and make a decision on for themselves whether you should continue to buy their product
Hi Everyone, my name is Jason and I am the owner of Erie Brush. I feel like I should be part of this conversation so it’s known how we are and continuing to handle this specific scenario of the original poster. I will bend over backwards for customers and do pretty much anything to make a situation right especially if it's a manufacturing issue. Below is what transpired on my side.

Kleen-Rite reached out on Aug 29 to tell us a customer is having some issues with around 40 brushes. My office manager asked to have the brushes sent back so we can examine them and determine what any issue is and if needed, figure out how to not let it happen again. We take this very serious and I definitely will and do lose sleep over the slightest customer issue.

About a month later, Sept 25 we received 36 brushes from KR that the customer had sent to them. For each brush, I personally examined them, took a photo of each, and wrote down a description of the condition along with the date each was made. I don’t believe it was known, but we do put a date code on every brush that includes the initials of the person who made it and the month/year. I attached a pdf of all of the brushes sent back.

Here's what my brush examination resulted in:

23 of the 36 brushes are from 2020 (qty11), 2021 (qty 6) or 2022 (qty 6). So again, that’s 23 of the 36 that are 3, 4, and 5 years old.

Of most of those 23, most had perfect u-shaped wear patterns as shown in the pics and pdf attached. To anyone, it was a brush that had a nice full life of cleaning. I think it’s reasonable to say it’s hard for me to consider a brush that’s 3, 4, 5 years old and totally worn down, as we all know customers can really abuse the equipment, especially those brushes that had no life left to them. Of the remaining that were 2 years old or newer, the majority were either in excellent condition or had a pronounced u-shape meaning they were definitely nearing their end of life. But of the ones in excellent condition, I looked closely and on a couple, I did see a chip or two in the glue or slight lifting on the ends. So based on this, 2 brushes qualified for a warranty. In talking with KR, they said they were going to give a case to the customer and wanted me to go in half. I always want to be a good partner, but again, I could only go based on what was sent to me and what was sent was mostly brushes that went through a full lifecycle. I told them I identified 2 but can double it to 4 as a good faith gesture.

So again, from my perspective, I can only go based on what the customer sends me. In this case, I was sent mostly brushes that had a full life of cleaning. Fast forward and I see this post on the forum. I made KR aware and they provided the customers number and I called him. We talked for 47 minutes exactly. My point was that I can only go based on what I was sent. His point was he buys 200 brushes a year from KR and he sees a problem and I should accept his word and give him 40 brushes in return. It’s not that I don’t believe him either, but going based on someone saying something and sending brushes that are mostly old and fully loved, it’s just not something a small business can absorb to just send 40 brushes based on his word, especially hog’s hair which is in short demand, extremely expensive, and all around difficult to get.

But any brush that clearly has a manufacturing defect that’s reasonable in age will absolutely get warrantied. And to note, I’m not brushing this off, I have our epoxy vendors coming in Monday and they’ve already sent samples of our glue to the lab to ensure it still meets the expected performance thresholds plus I asked for ways to get more flexibility in the epoxy to resist cracks. I have several calls, emails and pictures to our plastic block vendor and working through how to get even more adhesion. It should be known though that absolutely nothing has changed here. Same epoxy for the last 20 years, same plastic block provider for at least that long, same process hand gluing every brush, and same employees, most have a 15-25 year tenure in that department. As far as the hog’s hair color, it changes since it comes from a hog. You have brunette hogs, blonde hogs, black-haired hogs. Myself, I like a nice brunette one, but the blonde ones are more fun. If there’s ever anything, compliment or complaint, I am always easy to reach. 773.477.9620. After hours, it rings my cell phone because I never want to miss a call.

Oh and original poster sent me a picture of a brush after our call. I don’t know the age, but I said I want that one back too and just sent a replacement 4.5" brush today with a return label to get the other one back. Oh and I called KR and upped it to 8 brushes. I reexamined the new ones he sent and while it’s not super evident beyond the 2, there's 2 others that have the slightest lifting in one part so 4 qualify and of course I doubled that to 8 since i doubled it originally.

Sorry for all the words, hope this helps. One day, I’ll do a video on what goes into making a hog’s hair brush, it’ll be quite fascinating to most.

Thanks! Jason
 

Attachments

Erie Brush

New member
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
3
Reaction score
13
Points
3
After reading this thread yesterday, I checked my brushes and one that I installed about 2 months ago is missing clumps of bristles. I have round Erie brushes in the other bays and they don't appear to be having this problem.
Nice chatting with you. Thanks for the pic, your replacement went out today.
 

Erie Brush

New member
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
3
Reaction score
13
Points
3
I also have the same problem but not quite that bad. I contacted Erie a few years back about this exact issue and they replaced a few brush heads for me under warranty but not without a bit of a fight. They also claimed they were changing their manufacturing process to avoid these issues but I guess that wasn’t true. I also noticed the brushes are much darker in color than they used to be.

If anyone has a good alternative I am open to trying a different brand.
Hi there, I wasn't part of the company a few years ago but please reach out and ask for Jason and I'd love to help. 773-477-9620. There's really only 2 companies in the US that make hog's hair foaming brushes by hand. Erie and Universal. Coincidentally both are here in Chicago and both are going to provide a very high-quality brush. Because it's a natural bristle that is very hard to get, sometimes small issues might arise while the brush is in use at a car wash that is not able to be identified while making them. It doesn't happen very often thankfully, but nothing is perfect. In general though, you won't go wrong with either of us. We're both family-owned, small businesses who are trying to provide a living for our employees and families, just like most of you. In fact, I enjoy talking to them at the big ICA show and will occasionally grab a beer with the owner around here as well. Thanks, Jason
 
Top